在北大未名BBS (https://bbs.pku.edu.cn/) HSC （医学部）版近期进行的三次版务申请投票中，三位不同背景的申请者因不同的原因被投票否决。 其中，第一名申请者ducker是19级医学部在读本科生，主要反对理由为该同学较为年轻，不能胜任。 第二名申请者ccmesongshu是校本部19届毕业生，有一定的版务管理经验，主要反对理由为该同学为非医学部且为毕业生，不能胜任。 第三名申请者accept是医学部16级在读长学制临床研究生，主要反对理由为该同学临床事务繁忙，不能胜任。
根据未名BBS规定，版务投票为记名投票，结果公开。根据此公开数据做如下整理：
library(tidyverse)## -- Attaching packages --------------------------------------- tidyverse 1.3.1 --
## v ggplot2 3.3.3 v purrr 0.3.4
## v tibble 3.1.1 v dplyr 1.0.6
## v tidyr 1.1.3 v stringr 1.4.0
## v readr 1.4.0 v forcats 0.5.1
## -- Conflicts ------------------------------------------ tidyverse_conflicts() --
## x dplyr::filter() masks stats::filter()
## x dplyr::lag() masks stats::lag()
accept_result <- read_csv("accept.csv")##
## -- Column specification --------------------------------------------------------
## cols(
## ID = col_character(),
## IP = col_character(),
## time = col_character(),
## day = col_character(),
## choice = col_character()
## )
ccmesongshu_result <- read_csv("ccmesongshu.csv")##
## -- Column specification --------------------------------------------------------
## cols(
## ID = col_character(),
## IP = col_character(),
## time = col_character(),
## day = col_character(),
## choice = col_character()
## )
ducker_result <- read_csv("ducker.csv")##
## -- Column specification --------------------------------------------------------
## cols(
## ID = col_character(),
## IP = col_character(),
## time = col_character(),
## day = col_character(),
## choice = col_character()
## )
all_result <- full_join(accept_result, ccmesongshu_result, by = "ID", suffix = c(".accept", ".ccmesongshu")) %>%
full_join(ducker_result, by = "ID") %>%
mutate(choice.ducker = choice) %>%
select(ID, choice.accept, choice.ccmesongshu, choice.ducker)
knitr::kable(all_result)| ID | choice.accept | choice.ccmesongshu | choice.ducker |
|---|---|---|---|
| accept | A | A | NA |
| Admi | A | A | NA |
| afurol | A | NA | NA |
| amoykang | A | A | NA |
| arzthxy | B | B | NA |
| augatuniv | A | B | NA |
| axtoxic | A | NA | A |
| bailangdx | A | B | NA |
| bananaskin | A | A | NA |
| bias | B | B | NA |
| bigdouble | B | B | NA |
| biuJON | A | A | NA |
| bjdoufei | B | B | NA |
| blueflash | A | NA | NA |
| bonfire | B | B | NA |
| bradtido | A | A | NA |
| bridgefly | A | A | NA |
| Brielle | B | B | NA |
| Briseis | B | B | NA |
| bwcx | B | B | NA |
| catalyze | A | A | NA |
| ccmesongshu | A | NA | NA |
| cgbdycz | B | B | NA |
| cxaicx | B | B | NA |
| Delusional | A | A | NA |
| derive | B | B | NA |
| desmondliang | A | A | NA |
| Destinii | B | B | NA |
| docidaci | B | B | NA |
| doctorfree | A | A | NA |
| ducker | A | A | NA |
| dvoraz | A | A | NA |
| Eden | B | B | NA |
| edenhazard | A | A | NA |
| eeeKd | B | B | NA |
| Einsieben | A | NA | A |
| euio | A | A | NA |
| EulerHuaji | A | A | NA |
| EzawaTamiko | A | A | NA |
| faruxue | B | B | NA |
| Fireworks | A | A | NA |
| fundamental | A | A | NA |
| gaodi | B | B | NA |
| gol | A | A | B |
| Hangovers | B | B | NA |
| hanhanmei | B | B | NA |
| HANZPAN | A | A | A |
| HelloOTS | A | NA | A |
| hhhhhhhhhhh | B | B | NA |
| himitsu | A | A | NA |
| houbuhoua | A | A | NA |
| hrcegg | A | A | NA |
| hscxcb | A | A | NA |
| idiocratic | A | A | NA |
| Iowa | A | A | NA |
| Iridaze | A | A | NA |
| jennyG | A | NA | NA |
| kanez | A | A | NA |
| KennethPKU | A | A | NA |
| kitdzlove | B | B | NA |
| lemonlemon | B | B | NA |
| leppapebc | A | A | NA |
| LH | A | A | NA |
| Lithium | A | A | NA |
| lizx | A | A | NA |
| lnpku | A | A | NA |
| lohas | B | B | NA |
| lxy | A | A | NA |
| lyhsunny | B | B | NA |
| maonster | A | A | NA |
| mojave | A | A | NA |
| Moony | A | A | NA |
| motaguoke | A | A | NA |
| MrWolffy | A | A | NA |
| muktub | B | B | NA |
| Nachtmusik | A | A | A |
| nancycat | B | B | NA |
| Noah | B | B | NA |
| pangshuaige | A | A | NA |
| pinellia | B | B | NA |
| pkuerljh | A | A | NA |
| Purpose | A | NA | NA |
| puzhe | A | A | NA |
| Qiiiiii | A | A | NA |
| ququlongsha | A | A | NA |
| RayPrime | A | A | NA |
| Reines | A | A | NA |
| RichardGreen | A | A | NA |
| rlcheng | A | A | NA |
| Rorschach | B | B | NA |
| ryanli | A | A | NA |
| sanshan | A | A | NA |
| shuchong | A | NA | NA |
| sjwclwnayz | A | A | NA |
| skygs | B | B | B |
| soniaw | B | B | NA |
| spiridempt | A | A | NA |
| SQ | A | A | NA |
| SrinceW | A | A | A |
| ssssuuuu | B | B | NA |
| stonez | A | A | NA |
| survivor | A | A | NA |
| sweetmonkey | B | B | NA |
| Talutsai | A | A | A |
| tangmo | A | A | A |
| Tavstar | A | A | A |
| Tool | B | B | NA |
| Tranquilsun | A | A | NA |
| tsiau | A | A | A |
| Velpro | B | B | NA |
| vitiger | A | A | NA |
| viviss | B | B | NA |
| vvvvic | B | B | NA |
| watem | A | A | NA |
| webberjian | B | B | NA |
| wenxijc | A | NA | NA |
| wky | A | A | NA |
| woctordho | A | A | NA |
| wuyuchuan | A | A | NA |
| xiaohehe | A | A | NA |
| XuLanTu | A | A | NA |
| xuziling | B | B | NA |
| yuanhuang | A | A | NA |
| YvonneLLL | A | A | NA |
| yydcj | A | A | NA |
| zaiqiang | A | A | NA |
| zaza | A | A | A |
| ZBFSZX | B | A | B |
| ZelmaYoung | B | B | B |
| zinccat | A | A | NA |
| ZQM | A | A | B |
| moonl | NA | A | NA |
| ARABBIT | NA | A | NA |
| starlight | NA | A | NA |
| docu | NA | A | NA |
| dengrun | NA | A | NA |
| thedoor | NA | B | NA |
| enozi | NA | B | NA |
| Pip | NA | B | NA |
| lululux | NA | B | NA |
| ckrenren | NA | A | NA |
| monicany | NA | B | NA |
| zhanyihe | NA | A | NA |
| psychosocial | NA | B | NA |
| anotso | NA | NA | A |
| astrolabe | NA | NA | B |
| Chiilin | NA | NA | B |
| conezy | NA | NA | A |
| craneth | NA | NA | B |
| dodobus | NA | NA | A |
| echoes | NA | NA | B |
| GuNai | NA | NA | B |
| hnll | NA | NA | A |
| HuayuSi | NA | NA | B |
| idudu | NA | NA | A |
| Keib | NA | NA | A |
| kzhengPKU | NA | NA | A |
| momohong | NA | NA | B |
| nashishenme | NA | NA | B |
| parsio | NA | NA | B |
| pencilpop | NA | NA | B |
| pkuhb | NA | NA | A |
| qinwei | NA | NA | A |
| qui | NA | NA | B |
| Shadow | NA | NA | B |
| SheeranYoung | NA | NA | B |
| Shirleen | NA | NA | B |
| steveblade | NA | NA | A |
| wenjiajia | NA | NA | A |
| wuxian | NA | NA | A |
| WZzzxxx | NA | NA | B |
| xinglian | NA | NA | A |
| yuewuzhen | NA | NA | B |
| yxlixiang | NA | NA | A |
| zhangercheng | NA | NA | B |
| zznizhidao | NA | NA | B |
其中，各ID投下反对票的次数统计如下：
B_result <- all_result %>%
rowwise() %>%
mutate(B_num = sum(c(choice.accept, choice.ccmesongshu, choice.ducker) == "B", na.rm = T)) %>%
ungroup() %>%
arrange(-B_num)
knitr::kable(B_result)| ID | choice.accept | choice.ccmesongshu | choice.ducker | B_num |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| skygs | B | B | B | 3 |
| ZelmaYoung | B | B | B | 3 |
| arzthxy | B | B | NA | 2 |
| bias | B | B | NA | 2 |
| bigdouble | B | B | NA | 2 |
| bjdoufei | B | B | NA | 2 |
| bonfire | B | B | NA | 2 |
| Brielle | B | B | NA | 2 |
| Briseis | B | B | NA | 2 |
| bwcx | B | B | NA | 2 |
| cgbdycz | B | B | NA | 2 |
| cxaicx | B | B | NA | 2 |
| derive | B | B | NA | 2 |
| Destinii | B | B | NA | 2 |
| docidaci | B | B | NA | 2 |
| Eden | B | B | NA | 2 |
| eeeKd | B | B | NA | 2 |
| faruxue | B | B | NA | 2 |
| gaodi | B | B | NA | 2 |
| Hangovers | B | B | NA | 2 |
| hanhanmei | B | B | NA | 2 |
| hhhhhhhhhhh | B | B | NA | 2 |
| kitdzlove | B | B | NA | 2 |
| lemonlemon | B | B | NA | 2 |
| lohas | B | B | NA | 2 |
| lyhsunny | B | B | NA | 2 |
| muktub | B | B | NA | 2 |
| nancycat | B | B | NA | 2 |
| Noah | B | B | NA | 2 |
| pinellia | B | B | NA | 2 |
| Rorschach | B | B | NA | 2 |
| soniaw | B | B | NA | 2 |
| ssssuuuu | B | B | NA | 2 |
| sweetmonkey | B | B | NA | 2 |
| Tool | B | B | NA | 2 |
| Velpro | B | B | NA | 2 |
| viviss | B | B | NA | 2 |
| vvvvic | B | B | NA | 2 |
| webberjian | B | B | NA | 2 |
| xuziling | B | B | NA | 2 |
| ZBFSZX | B | A | B | 2 |
| augatuniv | A | B | NA | 1 |
| bailangdx | A | B | NA | 1 |
| gol | A | A | B | 1 |
| ZQM | A | A | B | 1 |
| thedoor | NA | B | NA | 1 |
| enozi | NA | B | NA | 1 |
| Pip | NA | B | NA | 1 |
| lululux | NA | B | NA | 1 |
| monicany | NA | B | NA | 1 |
| psychosocial | NA | B | NA | 1 |
| astrolabe | NA | NA | B | 1 |
| Chiilin | NA | NA | B | 1 |
| craneth | NA | NA | B | 1 |
| echoes | NA | NA | B | 1 |
| GuNai | NA | NA | B | 1 |
| HuayuSi | NA | NA | B | 1 |
| momohong | NA | NA | B | 1 |
| nashishenme | NA | NA | B | 1 |
| parsio | NA | NA | B | 1 |
| pencilpop | NA | NA | B | 1 |
| qui | NA | NA | B | 1 |
| Shadow | NA | NA | B | 1 |
| SheeranYoung | NA | NA | B | 1 |
| Shirleen | NA | NA | B | 1 |
| WZzzxxx | NA | NA | B | 1 |
| yuewuzhen | NA | NA | B | 1 |
| zhangercheng | NA | NA | B | 1 |
| zznizhidao | NA | NA | B | 1 |
| accept | A | A | NA | 0 |
| Admi | A | A | NA | 0 |
| afurol | A | NA | NA | 0 |
| amoykang | A | A | NA | 0 |
| axtoxic | A | NA | A | 0 |
| bananaskin | A | A | NA | 0 |
| biuJON | A | A | NA | 0 |
| blueflash | A | NA | NA | 0 |
| bradtido | A | A | NA | 0 |
| bridgefly | A | A | NA | 0 |
| catalyze | A | A | NA | 0 |
| ccmesongshu | A | NA | NA | 0 |
| Delusional | A | A | NA | 0 |
| desmondliang | A | A | NA | 0 |
| doctorfree | A | A | NA | 0 |
| ducker | A | A | NA | 0 |
| dvoraz | A | A | NA | 0 |
| edenhazard | A | A | NA | 0 |
| Einsieben | A | NA | A | 0 |
| euio | A | A | NA | 0 |
| EulerHuaji | A | A | NA | 0 |
| EzawaTamiko | A | A | NA | 0 |
| Fireworks | A | A | NA | 0 |
| fundamental | A | A | NA | 0 |
| HANZPAN | A | A | A | 0 |
| HelloOTS | A | NA | A | 0 |
| himitsu | A | A | NA | 0 |
| houbuhoua | A | A | NA | 0 |
| hrcegg | A | A | NA | 0 |
| hscxcb | A | A | NA | 0 |
| idiocratic | A | A | NA | 0 |
| Iowa | A | A | NA | 0 |
| Iridaze | A | A | NA | 0 |
| jennyG | A | NA | NA | 0 |
| kanez | A | A | NA | 0 |
| KennethPKU | A | A | NA | 0 |
| leppapebc | A | A | NA | 0 |
| LH | A | A | NA | 0 |
| Lithium | A | A | NA | 0 |
| lizx | A | A | NA | 0 |
| lnpku | A | A | NA | 0 |
| lxy | A | A | NA | 0 |
| maonster | A | A | NA | 0 |
| mojave | A | A | NA | 0 |
| Moony | A | A | NA | 0 |
| motaguoke | A | A | NA | 0 |
| MrWolffy | A | A | NA | 0 |
| Nachtmusik | A | A | A | 0 |
| pangshuaige | A | A | NA | 0 |
| pkuerljh | A | A | NA | 0 |
| Purpose | A | NA | NA | 0 |
| puzhe | A | A | NA | 0 |
| Qiiiiii | A | A | NA | 0 |
| ququlongsha | A | A | NA | 0 |
| RayPrime | A | A | NA | 0 |
| Reines | A | A | NA | 0 |
| RichardGreen | A | A | NA | 0 |
| rlcheng | A | A | NA | 0 |
| ryanli | A | A | NA | 0 |
| sanshan | A | A | NA | 0 |
| shuchong | A | NA | NA | 0 |
| sjwclwnayz | A | A | NA | 0 |
| spiridempt | A | A | NA | 0 |
| SQ | A | A | NA | 0 |
| SrinceW | A | A | A | 0 |
| stonez | A | A | NA | 0 |
| survivor | A | A | NA | 0 |
| Talutsai | A | A | A | 0 |
| tangmo | A | A | A | 0 |
| Tavstar | A | A | A | 0 |
| Tranquilsun | A | A | NA | 0 |
| tsiau | A | A | A | 0 |
| vitiger | A | A | NA | 0 |
| watem | A | A | NA | 0 |
| wenxijc | A | NA | NA | 0 |
| wky | A | A | NA | 0 |
| woctordho | A | A | NA | 0 |
| wuyuchuan | A | A | NA | 0 |
| xiaohehe | A | A | NA | 0 |
| XuLanTu | A | A | NA | 0 |
| yuanhuang | A | A | NA | 0 |
| YvonneLLL | A | A | NA | 0 |
| yydcj | A | A | NA | 0 |
| zaiqiang | A | A | NA | 0 |
| zaza | A | A | A | 0 |
| zinccat | A | A | NA | 0 |
| moonl | NA | A | NA | 0 |
| ARABBIT | NA | A | NA | 0 |
| starlight | NA | A | NA | 0 |
| docu | NA | A | NA | 0 |
| dengrun | NA | A | NA | 0 |
| ckrenren | NA | A | NA | 0 |
| zhanyihe | NA | A | NA | 0 |
| anotso | NA | NA | A | 0 |
| conezy | NA | NA | A | 0 |
| dodobus | NA | NA | A | 0 |
| hnll | NA | NA | A | 0 |
| idudu | NA | NA | A | 0 |
| Keib | NA | NA | A | 0 |
| kzhengPKU | NA | NA | A | 0 |
| pkuhb | NA | NA | A | 0 |
| qinwei | NA | NA | A | 0 |
| steveblade | NA | NA | A | 0 |
| wenjiajia | NA | NA | A | 0 |
| wuxian | NA | NA | A | 0 |
| xinglian | NA | NA | A | 0 |
| yxlixiang | NA | NA | A | 0 |