Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

Sign up for GitHub

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Jump to bottom

Menu bar item position keeps resetting on macOS Monterey #555

Closed
linuswillner opened this issue Nov 10, 2021 · 3 comments
Closed

Menu bar item position keeps resetting on macOS Monterey #555

linuswillner opened this issue Nov 10, 2021 · 3 comments
Labels
bug Done in beta Top priority
Milestone
v1.5.11

Comments

@linuswillner
Copy link

linuswillner commented Nov 10, 2021 •
edited
Loading

Macs Fan Control 1.5.10 [Qt 5.15.6] MacBookPro16,1 [AC] CPU: Intel(R) Core(TM) i9-9880H CPU @ 2.30GHz [8 cores] macOS 12.0.1

Fans:
Left side-min{1836}curr{1845}max{5616}mode{0}
Right side-min{1700}curr{1685}max{5200}mode{0}

SMC sensors:
TA0V () - 22.9805, 22.9805
TB0T (Battery Max) - 25.0977, 25.0977
TB1T (Battery Sensor 1) - 24, 24
TB2T (Battery Sensor 2) - 25.0977, 25.0977
TC0E () - 57.9844, 57.9844
TC0F () - 59.7891, 59.7891
TC0P (CPU Proximity) - 51.6875, 51.6875
TC0T () - 255.762, 255.762
TC1C (CPU Core 1) - 51, 51
TC2C (CPU Core 2) - 50, 50
TC3C (CPU Core 3) - 50, 50
TC4C (CPU Core 4) - 50, 50
TC5C (CPU Core 5) - 49, 49
TC6C (CPU Core 6) - 49, 49
TC7C (CPU Core 7) - 49, 49
TC8C (CPU Core 8) - 50, 50
TCGC (GPU PECI) - 52, 52 [H]
TCMX () - 52, 52
TCSA () - 50, 50
TCXC (CPU PECI) - 51.7656, 51.7656
TF0S () - 4.28125, 4.28125
TG0P (GPU Proximity) - 46.6875, 46.6875
TG1P (GPU Proximity 2) - 44.25, 44.25
TGDD (GPU Diode 2) - 35, 35 [H]
TGDE () - 35, 35
TGDF () - 36.3711, 36.3711
TGDT () - 0, 0
TGVF () - 39.1875, 39.1875
TGVP () - 39.1875, 39.1875
TH0F () - 34.6875, 34.6875
TH0X () - 34.8711, 34.8711
TH0a () - 32.1094, 32.1094
TH0b () - 34.8711, 34.8711
TH1a () - 26.668, 26.668
TH1b () - 27.707, 27.707
TM0P (Memory Proximity) - 47.0625, 47.0625
TPCD (Platform Controller Hub Die) - 45, 45
TTLD () - 45.5, 45.5
TTRD () - 28.6875, 28.6875
TW0P (Airport Proximity) - 48.4375, 48.4375
TaLC () - 39.75, 39.75
TaRC () - 29.875, 29.875
Th1H (Heatsink Proximity) - 43.4375, 43.4375
Th2H () - 49.75, 49.75
Tm0P () - 49.8125, 49.8125
Ts0P (Palm Rest) - 25.9961, 25.9961
Ts0S () - 31.8828, 31.8828
Ts1P () - 22.9961, 22.9961
Ts1S () - 34.4922, 34.4922
Ts2S () - 31.7695, 31.7695

GPUs:
Intel UHD Graphics 630 - 57
AMD Radeon Pro 5500M - 0

Disk drives:
APPLE SSD AP1024N - 25

Path: /Applications/Macs Fan Control.app/Contents/MacOS/Macs Fan Control

Log:

[2021-11-10 09:01:48:269] [thread 5134] [app.cpp#305] Macs Fan Control 1.5.10
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:269] [thread 5134] [app.cpp#306] macOS 12.0.1
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:269] [thread 5134] [app.cpp#307] MacBookPro16,1
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:269] [thread 5134] [app.cpp#308] Intel(R) Core(TM) i9-9880H CPU @ 2.30GHz [8 cores]
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:269] [thread 5134] [app.cpp#309] Qt 5.15.6
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:285] [thread 5134] [smcWriteInstaller.mm#69] Helper installed (version 1.0.2)
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:285] [thread 5134] [smcWriteInstaller.mm#70] Helper file path: /Library/PrivilegedHelperTools/com.crystalidea.macsfancontrol.smcwrite
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:285] [thread 5134] [smcWriteInstaller.mm#71] Helper file size: 189712 bytes
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:286] [thread 5134] [smcWriteInstaller.mm#85] Current version - 1.0.2
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:287] [thread 5134] [Platform_mac_smcwrite.mm#79] open XPC connection to com.crystalidea.macsfancontrol.smcwrite
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:287] [thread 5134] [Platform_mac_smcwrite.mm#150] process_command_open: OK
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:287] [thread 5134] [Service.cpp#91] detectSmcFanKeySize KeyType flt
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:288] [thread 5134] [Service.cpp#92] detectSmcFanKeySize KeyLen 4
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:288] [thread 5134] [Platform_mac.mm#188] getKeyInfo, the key FS! doesn't likely exist
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:532] [thread 5134] [UpdateChecker.cpp#586] UpdateChecker: check (force = false)
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:550] [thread 5464] [FanControl.cpp#206] initialLoadThread
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:550] [thread 5464] [FanControl.cpp#162] QFanControl::loadFansFromSMC
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:551] [thread 5464] [FanControl.cpp#168] Fans count - 2
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:551] [thread 5464] [FanControl.cpp#185] Fan 0: Left side
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:553] [thread 5464] [FanControl.cpp#185] Fan 1: Right side
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:555] [thread 5464] [FanControl.cpp#61] checkFansControlModeFromSMC
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:557] [thread 5464] [TempSensorProvider.cpp#89] TemperatureSensorProvider::loadAvailableSensors
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:558] [thread 5464] [Service.cpp#60] getSMCKeysCount: 3573743616 981
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:569] [thread 5464] [Service.cpp#562] Locating temperature SMC keys
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:596] [thread 5464] [Service.cpp#608] 50 keys found
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:611] [thread 5464] [Provider_mac.mm#266] discoverGPUs started
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:625] [thread 5464] [Provider_mac.mm#349] addGPU Intel UHD Graphics 630 with MTLDevice
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:625] [thread 5464] [Provider_mac.mm#20] Device hold Intel(R) UHD Graphics 630
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:628] [thread 5464] [Provider_mac.mm#349] addGPU AMD Radeon Pro 5500M with MTLDevice
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:628] [thread 5464] [Provider_mac.mm#20] Device hold AMD Radeon Pro 5500M
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:631] [thread 5464] [Provider_mac_watcher.mm#82] eGPUWatcher started
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:631] [thread 5464] [TempSensorGPU.cpp#74] Integrated GPU: Intel UHD Graphics 630, matching SMC - yes
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:631] [thread 5464] [TempSensorGPU.cpp#91] Discrete GPU: GPU AMD Radeon Pro 5500M, matching SMC - yes
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:647] [thread 5464] [TempSensorProvider.cpp#33] Using TC1C sensor for CPU Core average
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:647] [thread 5464] [TempSensorProvider.cpp#33] Using TC2C sensor for CPU Core average
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:647] [thread 5464] [TempSensorProvider.cpp#33] Using TC3C sensor for CPU Core average
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:647] [thread 5464] [TempSensorProvider.cpp#33] Using TC4C sensor for CPU Core average
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:647] [thread 5464] [TempSensorProvider.cpp#33] Using TC5C sensor for CPU Core average
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:647] [thread 5464] [TempSensorProvider.cpp#33] Using TC6C sensor for CPU Core average
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:647] [thread 5464] [TempSensorProvider.cpp#33] Using TC7C sensor for CPU Core average
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:647] [thread 5464] [TempSensorProvider.cpp#33] Using TC8C sensor for CPU Core average
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:647] [thread 5464] [TempSensorProvider.cpp#138] InitialLoadThread: number of supported SMC sensors: 23
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:647] [thread 5464] [TempSensorProvider.cpp#139] InitialLoadThread: number of supported DISK sensors: 1
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:647] [thread 5464] [TempSensorProvider.cpp#140] InitialLoadThread: number of supported GPU sensors: 2
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:648] [thread 5464] [Platform_mac_smcwrite.mm#251] process_command_write: SMCWriteKey F0Md 00 OK
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:648] [thread 5464] [Service.cpp#515] Set fan 0 mode 0
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:649] [thread 5464] [Platform_mac_smcwrite.mm#251] process_command_write: SMCWriteKey F1Md 00 OK
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:649] [thread 5464] [Service.cpp#515] Set fan 1 mode 0
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:717] [thread 5485] [TempSensorGPU.cpp#27] Reading of GPU temperature failed
[2021-11-10 09:01:48:717] [thread 5485] [TempSensorGPU.cpp#32] Trying SMC instead
[2021-11-10 09:03:20:821] [thread 5134] [Service.cpp#686] getTemperature - skipping sensor TC0T with value of 255.785
[2021-11-10 09:03:20:829] [thread 5134] [Service.cpp#686] getTemperature - skipping sensor TGDT with value of 0.0
[2021-11-10 09:03:27:000] [thread 5134] [Service.cpp#686] getTemperature - skipping sensor TGDT with value of 0.0
[2021-11-10 09:04:47:520] [thread 5134] [Service.cpp#686] getTemperature - skipping sensor TC0T with value of 255.762
[2021-11-10 09:04:47:525] [thread 5134] [Service.cpp#686] getTemperature - skipping sensor TGDT with value of 0.0

Since updating to macOS Monterey (unsure if updating the app to the latest version also affected this), the menu bar item keeps constantly moving to the left end of the menu bar. This is an issue not only from the perspective of constantly overriding user preference, but also causes issues when used in conjunction with /~https://github.com/Mortennn/Dozer, as the icon keeps getting hidden and thus obscures the fan speed from monitoring. This seems to be an issue with this app specifically, as all the other apps remember their positions just fine.

Any advice for how to fix this would be appreciated.
@kleuter kleuter modified the milestones: v1.6.0, v1.5.11 Nov 10, 2021
@kleuter
Copy link
Member

kleuter commented Nov 11, 2021

It's actually an Apple bug:
feedback-assistant/reports#200

Anyway we made a workaround, should be fine in the beta now.

@kleuter
Copy link
Member

kleuter commented Nov 11, 2021

#548

@kleuter kleuter mentioned this issue Nov 11, 2021
Closed
@linuswillner
Copy link
Author

linuswillner commented Nov 14, 2021 •
edited
Loading

Works like a charm with the beta version, thanks!

(One thing I did notice is that initially, it moved my Dozer icons around, but since this is already a workaround, I'm not bothered. It was only a one-time thing too, everything stayed nicely in place after that.)

@kleuter kleuter closed this as completed Nov 16, 2021
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Assignees
No one assigned
Labels
bug Done in beta Top priority
Projects
None yet
Milestone
v1.5.11
Development

No branches or pull requests
2 participants
@kleuter @linuswillner